ADVERTISEMENT

National emergency

Never at any point in this conversation did my dialogue revolve around the wall. I was addressing the false narrative that illegal immigrants are less likely to be criminals than American citizens.
Oh, welcome to this thread about the wall
 
.


No one is suggesting that illegal immigrants are inherently better than American citizens. At least I’m not. But I would ask you to consider that people who are here illegally might be more prone to keep a low profile out of concern they might get caught and sent back. I’ve never asked any Mexican/Guatemalan/Honduran immigrants I work around on construction job sites whether they are here legally or illegally. But I do notice that very often the boss, usually a Mexican who most certainly is here legally will drive to the job with his automobile/pickup/van full of his employees. I have always assumed he gives them a ride to avoid any possibility they would be in an accident or get pulled over for a traffic violation, thus keeping them out of harm’s way.

I admit my experience is purely anecdotal, but I think it underscores a point that illegals may be less apt to commit a crime for the reason described above.

100% agree they keep a low profile. Kiss ass and stay low. And contractors constantly hire a legal el jefe that rolls out his own illegal crew. Hell the roofing industry would collapse.
 
Let me stop you right there. Yes there are people suggesting exactly that, and I never said you were.
Perhaps I have not read this thread as closely as I should have, but I don’t recall anyone making such a claim.

It seems to me you are trying to have it both ways. On the one hand you are arguing that illegal crime statistics are as bad or worse than those of native born Americans. Which they have interpreted as you saying “they” are more “evil” than “us.” Which you flatly deny, as you rightly should since you have made no such assertion. On the other hand they are arguing illegal crime statistics are superior to native crime statistics, which you are interpreting as they claiming “immigrants” are better than “us,” even though they have not made any such assertion. At least that’s how it appears to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Been Jammin
Oh, welcome to this thread about the wall

KPe8.gif
 
Perhaps I have not read this thread as closely as I should have, but I don’t recall anyone making such a claim.

It seems to me you are trying to have it both ways. On the one hand you are arguing that illegal crime statistics are as bad or worse than those of native born Americans. Which they have interpreted as you saying “they” are more “evil” than “us.” Which you flatly deny, as you rightly should since you have made no such assertion. On the other hand they are arguing illegal crime statistics are superior to native crime statistics, which you are interpreting as they claiming “immigrants” are better than “us,” even though they have not made any such assertion. At least that’s how it appears to me.

Dan, you are overthinking this. I've explained it clearly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GunsOfFrankEaton
100% agree they keep a low profile. Kiss ass and stay low. And contractors constantly hire a legal el jefe that rolls out his own illegal crew. Hell the roofing industry would collapse.

No it wouldn’t. Roofs would become more expensive.

But thank god you’ve had those disposable Mexicans without being subjected to labor laws and healthcare for a dangerous construction field.
 
Here's where we disagree. Yes, it was a campaign promise but it's also an attempt by the President to stop this invasion of people, drugs and whatever else is illegally coming into this country. I'm a bit more effected by this invasion since I was born and reared within 10 miles of the border in the RGV. I've seen and heard of these people illegally coming across the border my entire life and heard stories of the same dating back to the 1910's. (As stated in another thread weeks ago, I also worked with what is now CBP/ICE and have first hand knowledge of this invasion albeit not recently.) My Mother owns a farm in Mercedes which she leases to a farmer. We are told repeatedly about illegals walking through and camping on her farm destroying crops. I still have numerous relatives who live there who tell similar stories. Aside from how it has an effect on my family---it's a violation of our sovereignty and illegal and is getting worse each year. I'd be for a wall on the northern border if we were being overrun by millions of Canadians illegally entering our country--but the action is on the southern border.

I listened to Kasich, now a CNN analyst, at lunch (captive to the TV in the restaurant) flapping his gums about this issue. What a colossal douchebag. He, like GWB and Jeb and many other GOPer are open border fans. But, did you know his Dad was a postal carrier?


You make a very convincing case, anecdotal though it may be. I have no doubt that Americans that have farms and ranches at or near the border sometimes feel as if there is an invasion. And for those people the situation may very well feel like a crisis, an emergency. And they have probably been howling like cats and dogs for somebody to do something about it. Your family’s experience seems to go back over 100 years. That has to be frustrating.

Under no circumstances do I dispute your experience or disavow your feelings on the matter. The point I have been trying to make to Harry is this has not been a major focal point on a national scale until DJT made a campaign issue out of it. Harry says it has been a nationwide concern for decades, while I disagree and think it is a made up emergency by a clever politician who exploits it for his own benefit.

Think back ten years ago, 2009. Do you recall a hew and cry for a wall to protect us from the ravaging hordes? Maybe there was and I’m just too feeble minded to remember. But I don’t recall it being a central tenet of either party back then.

At any rate I feel sorrow for what your family has gone through. I wish there could be a resolution to the whole thing. But IMO a wall is not a resolution.
 
Dan, you are overthinking this. I've explained it clearly.
I agree! You have explained your point of view with absolute clarity. What I’m saying is those who disagree with you are also explaning their point with the same clarity. You just disagree with each other. It would be most helpful if both sides would recognize that and not try to paint the other as being unreasonable.
 
Last edited:
It would be most helpful if both sides would recognize that and not try to paint the other as being unreasonable.

Ah yes, a big group hug, and:



everyone rides off into la-la-land; all problems solved.

Makes me wanna puke....
 
Regardless of how you feel about the wall, immigration, or illegals in general; it's intellectually dishonest to claim Trump started this shit.

The Dream Act was a dumpster fire just begging to happen and Obama decided toss gasoline on it by enacting DACA

When he grabs a microphone 100 times and screams that he'll build a wall and make Mexico pay for it and people cheer, there's a good faith argument that he started this shit. The wall is HIS demand. Mexico paying was HIS promise. "100%"
 
When he grabs a microphone 100 times and screams that he'll build a wall and make Mexico pay for it and people cheer, there's a good faith argument that he started this shit. The wall is HIS demand. Mexico paying was HIS promise. "100%"
While the dipshit Kenyan dick sucking monkey grinds his organ...

If you like your doctor you can keep your doctor...

If you like your plan you can keep your plan...

Save $2,500 a year!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: windriverrange
I agree! You have explained your point of view with absolute clarity. What I’m saying is those who disagree with you are also explaning their point with the same clarity. You just disagree with each other. It would be most helpful if both sides would recognize that and not try to paint the other as being unreasonable.

This may be the most annoyingly down the middle post of
I dunno, I can take one data point at a time and I took 15 minutes to isolate and source just one obvious metric (per capita homicide rate of the illegals vs natives) used by MAGA repeatedly and the proof for that one talking point, reduced to one big state, appears to be a fictional number and Cato's disproves it with a credible source. You posted that metric after Pilt pushed back.

You'll note I'm not crowing or "every time"ing this, this is being totally open minded. Trying anyhow.

And the illegals I know are model people. If you know them, its hard to reduce those flesh and blood people to which side of a fvxking line they're born on. It's not American. If they have the lead in their ass to gtfo of a bad place and walk across Mexico I'd rather share a country with them than xenophobic liars.

I don't accept at face value that their crimes are under reported, either. The idea of under-reporting illegal alien crime contemplates that the general public is less alarmed if the crime is committed by a foreigner? There's a ton of deferred and suspended sentences white trash gets that illegals probably dont get, too. Does this metric of reported crimes include those? Deferred sentences get expunged, at least in ok (I think. JD? Elsewhere too?) So an elected DA is gonna take it easy on an illegal that hurts an innocent constituent? Nope.

If they're disproportionately violent it should be easy to prove.

By the way....
Nearly 20% of US inmates are non-citizens.

giphy.gif
 
Last edited:
What is the problem with expecting zero illegal immigration? Seal the border and expect anyone wishing to enter this country to do it within the confines of the law. If they don't, send them back.

Leftists want the illegal numbers on the census to increase their House allotment. What motivation is there for the rest? The expectation that those entering the US follow our immigration laws is completely rational.
 
I am surprised the people on this board are actually praising a president to violate the constitution of USA.Illegal immigration has been a problem for over a hundred years when I was in Oklahoma it was a problem then also, and that was in 70's.. Being a political scientist and having read the US constitution in college at okla state I found it a beautiful document in fact I still have a copy of it. The reason the purse strings were given to the congress is very simple the founding fathers did not want an imperial president who could spend peoples money in anyway he wanted to. Lots of people have talked about other presidents who have declared national emergencies but none of the emergencies allowed the president to take money from other projects and spend it on a campaign promise.
Please don't get taken by a con man,and a failed business man, believe me I have followed Trump since he wrote his first book, and I have talked to several people from New York both conservative and liberals several years ago even before Obama became the
president and general view was that he was a con man. Have you forgotten Trump university or Trump steaks or his casinos (where the odds of casino winning is about 80%)
It is not a question of liberal or conservative it is the values both of them have and the way they hold them which are about the same even if they differ on various issues.
I have never talked to an American who did not hold the US constitution as sacred
and if you let your constitution go by the side then god knows what would happen..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Been Jammin
I am surprised the people on this board are actually praising a president to violate the constitution of USA.Illegal immigration has been a problem for over a hundred years when I was in Oklahoma it was a problem then also, and that was in 70's.. Being a political scientist and having read the US constitution in college at okla state I found it a beautiful document in fact I still have a copy of it. The reason the purse strings were given to the congress is very simple the founding fathers did not want an imperial president who could spend peoples money in anyway he wanted to. Lots of people have talked about other presidents who have declared national emergencies but none of the emergencies allowed the president to take money from other projects and spend it on a campaign promise.
Please don't get taken by a con man,and a failed business man, believe me I have followed Trump since he wrote his first book, and I have talked to several people from New York both conservative and liberals several years ago even before Obama became the
president and general view was that he was a con man. Have you forgotten Trump university or Trump steaks or his casinos (where the odds of casino winning is about 80%)
It is not a question of liberal or conservative it is the values both of them have and the way they hold them which are about the same even if they differ on various issues.
I have never talked to an American who did not hold the US constitution as sacred
and if you let your constitution go by the side then god knows what would happen..
I'm sure you expressed just as much righteous indignation at the previous president taking a dump all over the Constuitution on more than one occasion???
 
What is the problem with expecting zero illegal immigration? Seal the border and expect anyone wishing to enter this country to do it within the confines of the law. If they don't, send them back.

Leftists want the illegal numbers on the census to increase their House allotment. What motivation is there for the rest? The expectation that those entering the US follow our immigration laws is completely rational.
No one wants illegal immigrants, but the overwhelming majority come in on temporary Visas and overstay.......the wall will do nothing to stop that.........if we are going to spend this kind of money, spend it where it will help.......even during his speech yesterday he lied about huge amounts of drugs in cars and Semis coming across the southern boarder at non ports of entry........his own DHS says that is not true.......
 
No one wants illegal immigrants, but the overwhelming majority come in on temporary Visas and overstay.......the wall will do nothing to stop that.........if we are going to spend this kind of money, spend it where it will help.......even during his speech yesterday he lied about huge amounts of drugs in cars and Semis coming across the southern boarder at non ports of entry........his own DHS says that is not true.......
“No one wants illegal immigrants “


HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! Thanks for my morning laugh.
 
“No one wants illegal immigrants “


HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! Thanks for my morning laugh.
I am sure there are some idiots some where who do, there are idiots on both sides, but as a whole , neither side wants them..........My wife is a legal immigrant, back in 1992 it cost us over $2,000 and two years ( it took a little longer than normal because of my job) , but, I hate to see people cheat the system.....
 
I am sure there are some idiots some where who do, there are idiots on both sides, but as a whole , neither side wants them..........My wife is a legal immigrant, back in 1992 it cost us over $2,000 and two years ( it took a little longer than normal because of my job) , but, I hate to see people cheat the system.....
I wasn’t suggesting you wanted illegals. Many Democrat politicians want illegals to keep coming, as do many advocacy groups. That or completely open borders.
 
I'm sure you expressed just as much righteous indignation at the previous president taking a dump all over the Constuitution on more than one occasion???
And what were those MJD? Did they cost $Billions to fulfill a campaign promise?
 
I'm sure you expressed just as much righteous indignation at the previous president taking a dump all over the Constuitution on more than one occasion???
First please let me know when the last president violated the constitution, I am
not aware of it.I am not an American citizen or a resident, I don't live in America either.
My interest in American politigcs is because I lived in Oklahoma (as a legal resident)
and did my bachelors in political science.
I do visit every year because my in laws live in new york( They are American citizens)
and most of my info about Trump is from new yorkers including Giuliani who is trumps lawyer now.
 
First please let me know when the last president violated the constitution, I am
not aware of it.I am not an American citizen or a resident, I don't live in America either.
My interest in American politigcs is because I lived in Oklahoma (as a legal resident)
and did my bachelors in political science.
I do visit every year because my in laws live in new york( They are American citizens)
and most of my info about Trump is from new yorkers including Giuliani who is trumps lawyer now.

Your average New Yorker would change the Constitution tomorrow if they could to ban and confiscate guns and to regulate free speech.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GunsOfFrankEaton
No one wants illegal immigrants, but the overwhelming majority come in on temporary Visas and overstay.......the wall will do nothing to stop that.........if we are going to spend this kind of money, spend it where it will help.......even during his speech yesterday he lied about huge amounts of drugs in cars and Semis coming across the southern boarder at non ports of entry........his own DHS says that is not true.......
Oh, ok, hmmmm, so barriers on the southern border won't stop people from overstaying their visas so we shouldn't have barriers on the southern border to stop people from crossing it. Do you not realize how dumb that sounds?
 
Your average New Yorker would change the Constitution tomorrow if they could to ban and confiscate guns and to regulate free speech.
changing the constitution is different than violating the constitution. i think your impression of easterners is biased,not everybody wants to get rid of the 2nd amendment but yes lots of them want the assault weapons off the market and they want a more checks for people who want to buy guns.
 
I am surprised the people on this board are actually praising a president to violate the constitution of USA.Illegal immigration has been a problem for over a hundred years when I was in Oklahoma it was a problem then also, and that was in 70's.. Being a political scientist and having read the US constitution in college at okla state I found it a beautiful document in fact I still have a copy of it. The reason the purse strings were given to the congress is very simple the founding fathers did not want an imperial president who could spend peoples money in anyway he wanted to. Lots of people have talked about other presidents who have declared national emergencies but none of the emergencies allowed the president to take money from other projects and spend it on a campaign promise.
Please don't get taken by a con man,and a failed business man, believe me I have followed Trump since he wrote his first book, and I have talked to several people from New York both conservative and liberals several years ago even before Obama became the
president and general view was that he was a con man. Have you forgotten Trump university or Trump steaks or his casinos (where the odds of casino winning is about 80%)
It is not a question of liberal or conservative it is the values both of them have and the way they hold them which are about the same even if they differ on various issues.
I have never talked to an American who did not hold the US constitution as sacred
and if you let your constitution go by the side then god knows what would happen..
Complete horse shit. Get the **** out of here with your bullshit.
 
First please let me know when the last president violated the constitution, I am
not aware of it.I am not an American citizen or a resident, I don't live in America either.
My interest in American politigcs is because I lived in Oklahoma (as a legal resident)
and did my bachelors in political science.
I do visit every year because my in laws live in new york( They are American citizens)
and most of my info about Trump is from new yorkers including Giuliani who is trumps lawyer now.
What country are you a citizen? Getting your information about President Trump from a bunch of liberal New Yorkers. You sir are FAKE NEWS!
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT