AJ won a championship. Wittlake, Joe, and Kaid were All Americans. How anyone sees that as a failure is a mystery to me.
One could speculate that there was some mid season mismanagement. Joe Smith is the obvious case though we fans don't know the details. But AJ becoming college wrestling's #1 villain, Kaid and Travis both getting hurt three seasons in a row, and Mastro quitting to RUN A FREAKING ZOO... I don't know how you prepare for that kind of thing. Lol.
Takeaway for me is that OSU limped along but punched above its weight from like, 2015-2020. Then we had some pretty unique challenges in 2021-2023. Now the turnaround is in progress with changes in coaching, recruiting, training, fundraising, facilities, and the freestyle program. Pretty impressive considering how slowly institutions tend to change.
Any guy who makes a major power 5 program and wrestles at that level is someone to be respected. Winning conference titles and AA’s is a whole different level so I hate to ever bring some of those guys up.
But… we are discussing things that have held this program back from winning team titles and there are several who didn’t live up to the hope and pedigree of their recruiting profile. You mentioned a few here.