I have a 2010 Wrangler Rubicon that has been rock solid. Not one issue in 5 years that I would call significant. I think the only thing I can think of off the top of my head was the radio needed an update on the software. There was a recall on the rear brakes, but that was fixed immediately. Bought a Dodge Ram 1500 Hemi back in 2003, other than the right window actuator failing, I haven't had any issues with that either.
And I'm sure there are plenty of satisfied bimmer folks, and I was one of them back in 2005 with my first X5, but I have seen and experienced quite a few negatives to say the least on the newer products. Every car company has a few bad apples, but it's the overall amount of bad apples I have seen from BMW lately that is alarming. Couple that with the fact that I have spent waay too much time at around 91st and memorial getting loaner cars....and...yeesh. I quit that squad lol.
And it's funny, used to be easy to get a loaner from BMW when you had service done. The last few trips we made over there it was like pulling teeth to get one. They had become a "call center" or some such (I can't remember the details) and I was told they were experiencing a higher volume of service requests and getting a loaner was difficult. A couple times it was the lone factor (or loan factor, yuk yuk) on when we could actually get our car to the shop. Once, we had to go a couple days without a loaner. Just solidified my thoughts and I'm glad I no longer am slave to their service department lol.