Wittlake had a TF, then, 10-3, then 8-4 in the finals. Steiert had a MD 8-0, 4-1, then a pin in the finals. Picc was TF, MD, 3-1. Adams was 2-1, 7-4, and 5-1. Boo was TF, fall, 8-5. None of those were extremely outstanding in my opinion. They gave it to Nick, probably based on his 4 year accomplishment, rather than his performance in this tournament. While I am pleased that he got it, I think the award should be based solely on this tournament, in which case I would have gone with Boo or Steiert. I remember how upset all OSU fans were when Pendleton was clearly the best wrestler at NCAA's his senior (?) year, but the award was given to Greg Jones of West Virginia based on his 4 year record. If it's going to be a lifetime achievement award, then they need to rename it. Just my two cents.