Interesting Article

[2012Bearcat]

Yet you still hesitate to answer *why* Israel has a right to exist. I think it is because you don’t know why. Common sense ought to be strong enough to explain why.

Provided two different answers for you, you can accept them or not. That's up to you.

 

[Ponca Dan]

Provided two different answers for you, you can accept them or not. That's up to you.

LOL. Your "philosophical" answer is a joke and you know it, it makes you look stupid, but we both know you are not stupid. Your "real life" answer has some legs, but let's face it they are very short legs. The truth, which you are avoiding like the plague, is you don't know *why* Israel has a right to exist.

 

[2012Bearcat]

LOL. Your "philosophical" answer is a joke and you know it, it makes you look stupid, but we both know you are not stupid. Your "real life" answer has some legs, but let's face it they are very short legs. The truth, which you are avoiding like the plague, is you don't know *why* Israel has a right to exist.

I gave you my answers which you clearly don't like and want to discount. Now explain your position of why Israel doesn't have the right to exist.

 

[Ponca Dan]

I gave you my answers which you clearly don't like and want to discount. Now explain your position of why Israel doesn't have the right to exist.

I don’t have a position that Israel doesn’t have a right to exist.

 

[2012Bearcat]

I don’t have a position that Israel doesn’t have a right to exist.

Of then here is your opportunity to provide us with you all knowing knowledge. Why does Israel have the right to exist?

 

[Ponca Dan]

Of then here is your opportunity to provide us with you all knowing knowledge. Why does Israel have the right to exist?

It doesn't.

 

[2012Bearcat]

It doesn't.

I don’t have a position that Israel doesn’t have a right to exist.

Alzheimers kicking in?

 

[Ponca Dan]

Alzheimers kicking in?

On you? Oh, I hope not! Let me ask you what I asked Woody and he was stumped: does North Korea have a right to exist?

 

[2012Bearcat]

On you? Oh, I hope not! Let me ask you what I asked Woody and he was stumped: does North Korea have a right to exist?

Evidently so, they are a "country" recognized by the international community. They would lose that right as soon as they started a war.

You should be a Democrat politician Dan. You try to ride the fence, blame everyone else for failure, seldom if ever state your position and never take accountability for being wrong. All the qualities of a leftist Politician.

 

[Ponca Dan]

Evidently so, they are a "country" recognized by the international community. They would lose that right as soon as they started a war.

You should be a Democrat politician Dan. You try to ride the fence, blame everyone else for failure, seldom if ever state your position and never take accountability for being wrong. All the qualities of a leftist Politician.

Interesting! Did the USA lose its right to exist when LBJ started a war in Vietnam?

 

[2012Bearcat]

Interesting! Did the USA lose its right to exist when LBJ started a war in Vietnam?

Sure as soon as Viet Nam was able to defeat the US and take that right away. Oh and LBJ never declared war on Viet Nam, I would think you would know that having lived during that time.

 

[Ponca Dan]

Sure as soon as Viet Nam was able to defeat the US and take that right away. Oh and LBJ never declared war on Viet Nam, I would think you would know that having lived during that time.

Oh, I see. You can claim a right to exist after you start a war, but only if you don't declare it to be a war. That must explain why Russia calls its war with Ukraine a Special Military Operation. Otherwise the Bearcat Doctrine concludes Russia no longer has a right to exist. And the second portion says you can continue to have a right to exist only as long as you win the war you have or have not declared. You should write all this down and present your conclusions to the UN! Oh, and as a side note: Vietnam *did* defeat the US. Do you not remember the helter-skelter bugout? So should we assume you think Israel has a right to exist, but the US (which, ironically, is the only reason Israel continues to exist) has lost that right?