BTW, drinking age at the time was 18 (not 21). So drinking as a senior in high school would not have been illegal and thus his statements and membership in the 100 kegs club are not mutually exclusive. As for the Renate statement, unless you are going to call her to the stand to testify that she did or did not partake of him, you are basing your whole position on an interpretation of a 2 word byline in a 35 year-old yearbook.