BIG 12 FOOTBALL | BERRY TRAMEL’S EFFICIENCY RATINGS
Berry Tramel's Big 12 efficiency ratings: OSU defense finishes historically awful
- Dec 2, 2024 Updated 10 hrs ago
Sports Columnist
here’s nothing left to say about OSU football 2024, other than it was the most amazing crumble since the last time you stepped on a bag of Chips Ahoy.
A season that began with such promise quickly disintegrated into one of the worst teams in America.
OSU finished the season with a 52-0 loss at Colorado that gave the Cowboys a nine-game losing streak to carry into the offseason. OSU finishes 0-9 in the Big 12, two games behind Utah, Central Florida and Arizona, which were tied for next-to-last.
The Cowboys finish 13th in offensive efficiency and 16th, last place, in defensive efficiency.
OSU’s .489 rating on defense is indescribably awful. How bad was this season for the Cowboy defense? OSU held Colorado to six offensive touchdowns and a field goal in 14 possessions,
and that improved the Cowboys’ defensive efficiency.
Six straight opponents had averaged at least a touchdown every other possession.
OSU’s offensive plunge was notable only for being less dramatic than the defensive slide. Rebuilding this team is an undertaking not for the weak.
Let’s get to the final Big 12 efficiency ratings of the season, and remember, this is success rate based on opportunities. Touchdowns count full, field goals half, and that total is divided by possessions. Defensive rating is your opponents’ offensive efficiency.
Offense 1. Baylor .425: Amazing job by quarterback Sawyer Robertson and coordinator Jake Spavital. Through four power-conference games — admittedly against quality defenses Utah, Colorado, Brigham Young and Iowa State — the Bears had a .260 offensive efficiency. The last five games? A robust .545. 2. Arizona State .418: The Sun Devils played ball control. They averaged 9.8 possessions per game, the lowest in the Big 12. 3. TCU .418: Kendal Briles’ offense lit up the league. The Baylor offense still works. 4. Kansas .406: Jalon Daniels finally fell off in the season finale at Baylor, after a rousing four-game win streak. 5. Colorado .403: Five Big 12 teams above .400. Only one Southeastern Conference team was above .400. The Big 12 remains an offensive-focused league. 6. Texas Tech .391: Best Red Raider offense since 2016, when Patrick Mahomes quarterbacked Tech. 7. BYU .381: All that kept the Cougars out of the Big 12 Championship Game was that offensive stumble against Kansas. 8. Iowa State .381: Wow. A .381 offensive rating lands the Cyclones in the middle of the pack. 9. West Virginia .373: Offense wasn’t the reason Neal Brown got fired Sunday. These Mountaineers could score.
10. Kansas State .361: Still a good offense, even if the ‘Cats are far down the pack.
11. Cincinnati .350: The UC offense started strong but faded fast.
12. Central Florida .333: Gone, too, is Gus Malzahn, amid much offensive frustration. UCF should have been better than this.
13. Oklahoma State .284: Turns out, maybe Maealiuaki Smith isn’t the next Zac Robinson.
14. Arizona .250: We kept waiting for the Wildcat fire to start, and it never did.
15. Utah .207: The Utes never showed improvement after losing quarterback Cameron Rising so early in the season.
16. Houston .168: Big 12’s worst offense. That OU-Houston game back in September, matching two leagues’ worst offenses, was a beaut, I’m telling you.
Defense 1. Utah .234: What a waste of a tremendous defense.
2. Iowa State .254: The Cyclones didn’t waste good defense. They’re in the Big 12 Championship Game.
3. Colorado .267: The shutout of OSU helped lower this number.
4. Kansas State .282: Solid defense. Solid offense. I don’t know why the Wildcats finished 5-4 in the league.
5. BYU .303: Only Arizona State and OSU(?!) hurt the Cougar defense all season.
6. Houston .325: Excellent defensive work by a team that overachieved, despite its 4-8 record.
7. Arizona State .332: Interesting rating. A team this low in the ratings usually doesn’t make the league title game.
8. Cincinnati .338: Not bad. UC’s problems settled into offense.
9. TCU .358: This wouldn’t be so bad if the Frogs’ schedule wasn’t on the easy side.
10. Baylor .365: Dave Aranda is a defensive guru, but he ended up with a Lincoln Riley team.
11. Texas Tech .390: I guess when the Red Raiders’ offense gets good again, the defense is required to slide.
12. Central Florida .392: Can’t blame it all on fired coordinator Ted Roof.
13. Kansas .402: Not the first time the Jayhawks have been in the .400s on defense.
14. Arizona .430: A lost season.
15. West Virginia .467: Firing defensive coordinator Jordan Lesley a month ago didn’t save Brown’s job.
16. Oklahoma State .489: OSU’s defensive rating in the great season of 2021 was .150. That means these Cowboys allowed more than three times as many scores per possession.